The government is considering removing the Universal Credit health element from claimants under the age of 25, in a move that could affect around 184,000 young people across the UK currently receiving the payment.
The proposal, reported ahead of the outcome of the Timms and Milburn reviews into welfare, would see the health-related payment for under-25s replaced by a multibillion-pound package of employment support rather than scrapped outright, according to government sources.
What the health element is
The Universal Credit health element, also known as the limited capability for work and work-related activity (LCWRA) element, is an additional payment for claimants assessed through a work capability assessment as having both limited capability for work and limited capability for work-related activity, such as training. It is targeted at claimants with more severe and complex health conditions or disabilities.
Until April 2026, claimants received an extra £423 a month through the rate and were not required to look for work. From April 2026, the rate for new claimants was halved to £217 a month and frozen at that level, as part of earlier welfare changes.
The scale of the proposal
About 184,000 young people aged 16 to 24 currently receive the UC health element across the UK, representing roughly 6% of all recipients of the payment. The government is now reportedly looking at extending any change to existing claimants, not just new ones, a step that would affect a far larger group than earlier, narrower proposals that focused only on new claims.
In place of the health element, ministers are said to be considering a package including subsidised jobs for younger people, more targeted “back to work” schemes, additional mental health support, and tailored training and job coaching.
Concerns from charities
More than 40 organisations, including the National Association of Welfare Rights Advisers, have co-signed a letter to the Work and Pensions Secretary raising concerns about the proposals, warning that the young people affected often have severe and complex needs, frequently living with multiple physical and mental health conditions alongside overlapping disadvantages such as poverty, homelessness and childhood trauma.
The letter argued that evidence shows cutting benefits worsens health and deepens poverty, and that strict conditionality and sanctions are particularly counterproductive and harmful for disabled people, calling instead for reforms built around support and opportunity rather than what it described as the failed punitive approaches of the past.
Disability charity Scope has separately warned that around half of households with someone under 22 receiving the UC health element are already living in poverty, and estimated that figure could rise to more than 90% if the payment were removed without adequate replacement support.
Where things stand
A DWP spokesperson said the Milburn and Timms reviews, due in the autumn, would “lay the foundation for sustainable reform”, and that the government would not pre-empt their findings. A government source said ministers were preparing “a comprehensive package of support and reform to tackle the scandal of a million young people not in education, employment or training”, while insisting the details were yet to be decided and that the government remained committed to “enabling work and opportunity, while always protecting those unable to work”.
No final decision has been made, and any change would require new legislation, which could be introduced in Parliament next year. The government is also exploring related changes to Personal Independence Payment for under-25s, with ministers saying that those with the most severe disabilities would continue to receive support, though campaigners remain concerned about the overall direction of the reforms.
The policy backdrop
The proposal under consideration follows a series of welfare reforms introduced over the past two years aimed at reducing the overall benefits bill and encouraging more people judged capable of some work into employment. The halving of the health element rate for new claimants from April 2026 was part of the same broader package, alongside tighter eligibility rules for Personal Independence Payment and changes to the work capability assessment process used to determine who qualifies for additional support.
Ministers have repeatedly argued that the current system traps too many young people in long-term inactivity, pointing to the number of 16 to 24-year-olds who are not in education, employment or training, a figure often cited in government statements as evidence that the existing benefits structure, rather than supporting young people into work, in some cases entrenches worklessness instead.
How the reviews fit together
The Timms review, led by Sir Stephen Timms, and a separate review associated with former health secretary Alan Milburn, were established to examine different aspects of the welfare system, including how disability and incapacity benefits interact with employment support. Both reviews were expected to report in the autumn, with their findings likely to shape any formal legislative proposals brought before Parliament. The government has said repeatedly that it does not want to pre-empt either review’s conclusions, even as reports of specific options under consideration, including the under-25s proposal, have continued to circulate.
The debate over conditionality
A central tension in the proposals concerns conditionality, the principle that receipt of certain benefits can be made dependent on claimants taking specified steps toward work, such as attending job centre appointments or undertaking training. Supporters of greater conditionality argue it provides a necessary incentive and structure for people who might otherwise disengage from the labour market entirely. Critics, including many of the charities that signed the letter to the Work and Pensions Secretary, argue that conditionality and sanctions are poorly suited to claimants with complex health conditions, who may be unable to comply with requirements not because of unwillingness but because of the severity of their illness or disability.
Historical precedent
Previous attempts to tighten eligibility for incapacity-related benefits, including the introduction of the work capability assessment itself under a previous government, have often proved controversial and were subsequently modified after evidence emerged of people being wrongly found fit for work or experiencing serious harm as a result of benefit changes. Disability charities frequently cite this history when urging caution over new proposals, arguing that reforms affecting people with severe and complex needs require particularly careful design and evaluation before implementation.
What a replacement package might look like
Government sources have suggested any replacement for the health element among under-25s would involve a substantial package of employment support rather than a straightforward removal of financial support, potentially including subsidised job placements, intensive case-worker support, mental health provision and tailored training routes. The precise shape, funding and eligibility criteria of any such package have not yet been published, and charities have said they will be watching closely to see whether proposed support is sufficient and accessible enough to replace the certainty of a cash payment for young people with serious health conditions.
Parliamentary and political path ahead
Any formal change to Universal Credit eligibility rules of this kind would require legislation, giving MPs and peers an opportunity to scrutinise and potentially amend the proposals once they are formally introduced. Given the scale of opposition already expressed by disability charities and welfare rights organisations, the government is likely to face significant parliamentary and public debate over any eventual bill, particularly given previous rebellions within the governing party over welfare reform measures affecting disabled claimants.




