First Minister John Swinney has announced an independent review of the role of the Lord Advocate, examining whether one person should continue to combine the job of Scotland’s most senior prosecutor with that of the government’s chief legal adviser.

The review will be chaired by Lord Boyd of Duncansby, who himself served as Lord Advocate between 2000 and 2006, giving him direct first-hand experience of the dual role the review has been asked to scrutinise.

What the Lord Advocate does

The Lord Advocate is one of the two Scottish Law Officers, alongside the Solicitor General for Scotland, and holds a uniquely powerful dual position within the Scottish legal and political system. As head of the systems of criminal prosecution and investigation of deaths in Scotland, the Lord Advocate oversees the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and takes decisions on whether prosecutions proceed in serious cases. At the same time, the Lord Advocate also sits as the principal legal adviser to the Scottish Government, attending Cabinet and advising ministers on the legality of their decisions and legislation.

Why the arrangement is being questioned

That combination of roles, independent prosecutor on one hand and government adviser on the other, has long attracted debate among lawyers, academics and politicians, who have periodically questioned whether it creates a potential conflict of interest or at least a perception of one. Critics have argued that a Law Officer who sits in Cabinet and advises ministers may struggle to be seen as wholly independent when making prosecutorial decisions in cases with any political dimension, even where no actual impropriety occurs.

The question has particular resonance in Scotland given a series of controversies in recent years touching on the conduct of ministers, government agencies and public bodies, where the Lord Advocate’s decisions on prosecution have come under public and media scrutiny alongside their position as a government legal adviser.

Supporters of the current arrangement have countered that combining the two functions ensures the government receives legal advice from someone steeped in the practical realities of prosecution and the criminal justice system, and that safeguards, including the Lord Advocate’s independence from ministers in individual prosecutorial decisions, already protect against undue political influence over whether a case proceeds.

The scope of the review

The review will consider whether the current arrangement remains the most appropriate and effective model for Scotland, weighing the advantages and disadvantages of the Lord Advocate holding both the prosecutorial and government advisory functions. It will also examine alternative models for organising the Law Officer roles that might be used instead, potentially looking at how other jurisdictions separate or combine similar functions.

Other jurisdictions have adopted differing models for organising similar roles, with some separating prosecutorial independence entirely from government legal advice through distinct offices, while others retain combined arrangements broadly similar to Scotland’s. Lord Boyd’s review is expected to draw on comparisons of this kind as it considers whether reform is warranted.

Historical context

The office of Lord Advocate is one of the oldest in Scottish public life, with its prosecutorial functions dating back centuries, and its continued combination with a government advisory role has survived devolution and the creation of the Scottish Parliament in 1999. Previous reviews and debates about the office have periodically raised similar questions, but the role has until now remained largely unchanged in its core structure, making this review a significant moment for one of the oldest institutions in the Scottish justice system.

What happens next

Lord Boyd’s review is expected to report back with its findings and recommendations, although the Scottish Government’s announcement did not set out a fixed timetable for conclusion or for subsequent action by ministers. Any recommendation to split the Lord Advocate’s current functions, or to otherwise restructure the Law Officer roles, would likely require careful consideration of legislative change, given the office’s long-standing constitutional position within the Scottish legal system. Holyrood’s opposition parties are expected to take a close interest in the review’s conclusions, given the office’s significance to both the independence of prosecutions and the quality of legal advice available to government.