MSPs on several committees had flagged specific constituency and sector concerns ahead of the sessions, giving the exchanges a practical edge beyond general questions about the government’s overall programme.
The format has evolved over successive sessions of the Scottish Parliament, with the Conveners Group periodically reviewing how best to use its limited time with the First Minister to extract substantive answers on cross-cutting issues, rather than repeating questions already put to ministers in individual committee sessions throughout the year.
Previous First Ministers have also appeared before the Conveners Group periodically, and such sessions are generally seen at Holyrood as a useful supplement to First Minister’s Questions, allowing more detailed, less adversarial exchanges on the substance of government policy.
First Minister John Swinney is facing questions from the conveners of all 16 Holyrood committees in two public sessions, held on 30 September and 6 October, in his first appearances before the Scottish Parliament’s Conveners Group since his re-election in May.
Each session begins at 12:30pm and is expected to last around an hour, with members of the public able to attend and watch the exchanges take place.
What is the Conveners Group?
The Conveners Group brings together the chairs, known as conveners, of all of the Scottish Parliament’s committees. It allows them to share approaches to scrutiny and collectively press the Scottish Government for answers on issues that cut across individual committee remits, rather than leaving each committee to question ministers in isolation.
Sessions with the First Minister before the full Conveners Group are relatively rare and give conveners a chance to raise concerns from their own committees directly with the head of government, rather than through written correspondence or individual committee appearances by other ministers.
Possible topics for discussion include the Scottish Government’s Programme for Government, priorities ahead of the next Scottish Budget, and the government’s plans for wider public-sector reform, issues that touch on the work of almost every committee at Holyrood.
Who is asking the questions
The conveners taking part are split across the two sessions. They include Stuart McMillan, convener of the Climate Action Committee; David Linden of the Criminal Justice Committee; Calum Kerr of the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee; Karen Adam of the Education and Gaelic Committee; Katie Hagmann of the Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee; Paul Sweeney of the Public Petitions Committee; Mark Ruskell of the Rural Affairs Committee; and Jenni Minto of the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee.
Also taking part are Duncan Massey of the Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee; Patrick Harvie of the Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee; Clare Haughey of the Finance and Public Administration Committee; Helen McDade of the Health, Care and Sport Committee; Neil Bibby of the Public Audit Committee; Bob Doris of the Public Service Reform Committee; Craig Hoy of the Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Committee; and Willie Rennie of the Transport Committee.
Chaired by the Presiding Officer
The sessions are chaired by Presiding Officer Kenneth Gibson MSP, who leads the Conveners Group in his role overseeing the running of the Scottish Parliament. Gibson said committees are central to scrutinising the work of the Scottish Government, and that the sessions give conveners a public platform to put the First Minister “under the spotlight” on the issues their committees are following most closely.
Why committee scrutiny matters
Holyrood’s committee system was designed from the Parliament’s creation in 1999 to give MSPs cross-party powers to examine legislation, investigate policy areas and hold ministers to account outside of the more adversarial setting of First Minister’s Questions in the main chamber. Sessions like these, bringing together conveners from across the political spectrum, are intended to complement that chamber-based scrutiny with a more detailed, committee-level examination of government priorities.
What happens next
The Scottish Parliament’s website carries the schedule for both sessions and will publish the official report afterwards, recording in full what was asked and how the First Minister responded. Any changes to timing or format would also be posted there ahead of the sessions taking place.




