Highland Council planners are recommending that councillors raise no objection to the Glen Earrach pumped storage hydro scheme proposed for the shores of Loch Ness, according to a report prepared ahead of a planning committee meeting.

The council’s south planning committee is due to consider the recommendation on Wednesday 7 October, though the final decision on whether the project goes ahead rests not with the council but with Scottish ministers.

How the scheme would work

The project, put forward by developer Glen Earrach Limited, is proposed for the Balmaccan Estate, located between the villages of Drumnadrochit and Invermoriston on the western shore of Loch Ness. Pumped storage hydro schemes generate electricity by releasing water downhill through turbines from a higher reservoir, then pumping it back up using surplus electricity, typically from wind or solar generation, at times when demand is low.

In this case, water would be moved between a proposed upper reservoir at Loch nam Breac Dearga and Loch Ness itself, which would serve as the lower reservoir. The report notes an average height difference of around 480 metres between the two bodies of water, a substantial drop that would allow the scheme to generate significant amounts of electricity relative to its size, a characteristic that makes the Highlands attractive for this type of development given its steep terrain and abundance of lochs.

Why pumped storage matters for the grid

Pumped storage hydro is one of the few large-scale, proven technologies capable of storing electricity for extended periods and releasing it quickly when demand rises, a role increasingly seen as important as more of the UK’s electricity supply comes from intermittent renewable sources such as wind and solar. Scotland already hosts long-established pumped storage schemes, including at Cruachan and Foyers, and has seen a wave of new proposals in recent years driven by the expansion of offshore and onshore wind generation requiring storage and balancing capacity.

National Grid and energy regulators have repeatedly flagged a shortage of flexible, dispatchable storage as one of the barriers to integrating ever larger volumes of wind power onto the UK system without curtailing turbines on windy days when demand is low. Developers have responded with a string of proposed schemes across the Highlands over the past five years, several of which are now working their way through planning and consenting processes similar to the one Glen Earrach is navigating.

Access and design details

According to the planning report, the main construction access for the Glen Earrach scheme would be from an existing Forestry and Land Scotland car park exit at Balnain on the A831, roughly six kilometres west of Drumnadrochit. The report notes that final design details of the scheme, including aspects of construction logistics, could still change as the project progresses through further stages of assessment.

Projects of this scale typically involve years of construction, with earthworks for the upper reservoir, tunnelling to connect the two bodies of water, and the installation of turbines and associated electrical infrastructure all needing to be sequenced carefully to minimise disruption to the surrounding estate and nearby communities. Developers of comparable Highland pumped storage schemes have previously estimated construction periods running to the better part of a decade from the start of groundworks to full commissioning.

Local and environmental considerations

Large infrastructure projects on the shores of Loch Ness inevitably raise questions about landscape impact, given the area’s significance for tourism and its status within the wider Highland landscape, as well as potential effects on local wildlife and watercourses during construction. Planning committee reports of this kind typically weigh such considerations alongside the project’s wider contribution to Scotland’s renewable energy and grid-balancing capacity.

Loch Ness draws hundreds of thousands of visitors each year, and developers behind pumped storage proposals in the area have generally sought to argue that construction impacts can be managed and that completed schemes become a largely unobtrusive part of the landscape once operational, since much of the infrastructure, including tunnels and underground machine halls, is hidden from view. Local community councils and environmental groups are among the bodies likely to have submitted views during the consultation period that fed into the planning committee’s report.

Who makes the final call

Because of its scale, the Glen Earrach scheme falls into the category of nationally significant energy infrastructure, meaning the ultimate decision on whether it is consented lies with Scottish ministers rather than Highland Council. The council’s role is that of a statutory consultee, able to register its views, including any objection, for ministers to take into account, but without the power to block or approve the project itself. If the planning committee follows officers’ recommendation on 7 October, Highland Council’s formal response will be one of no objection, though this does not guarantee the scheme will ultimately receive ministerial consent.

Should ministers eventually grant consent, Glen Earrach would join a growing pipeline of pumped storage projects across the Highlands competing for grid connections, supply chains and skilled construction workers, all factors that are likely to shape how quickly, and in what order, these schemes are ultimately built out over the coming decade.