Fresh talks have begun between Glasgow City Council, the Unison trade union and Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth in an attempt to resolve a bitter dispute over a contested pay regrading system affecting thousands of council staff.
The discussions come after the council agreed to pause plans to dismiss and re-employ around 23,000 workers on new contractual terms, a move that had prompted strong opposition from unions representing council staff.
The roots of the dispute
The regrading system at the centre of the row is intended to replace an earlier pay structure that was found to discriminate against workers, the majority of them women, in traditionally female-dominated roles such as care and cleaning. Glasgow has already paid out hundreds of millions of pounds to settle historic equal pay claims following a long legal battle that forced the council to overhaul how it grades and pays its workforce.
According to reporting on the latest dispute, the new grading system that the council wants to introduce would leave around 11% of staff worse off financially, with some workers facing pay cuts of up to £11,000 a year. Unions argue this risks repeating some of the unfairness the original equal pay settlement was meant to correct, while the council maintains a fairer, more consistent grading structure is needed across its workforce.
To implement the changes, the council had proposed using fire-and-rehire, formally dismissing staff and offering them new contracts on the revised terms, a legally permitted but contentious tactic that unions have strongly opposed as it can be used to override opposition to pay and condition changes. The council agreed to pause this approach amid the escalating row.
Confusion over whether talks had collapsed
The dispute took an unusual turn this week when a council statement issued on Wednesday night suggested negotiations had broken down. The following day, at a council committee meeting, council leader Ricky Bell denied there had been any breakdown, saying discussions were continuing with both the GMB and Unite unions as well as Unison.
Councillors from the Scottish Greens put forward a motion calling on Mr Bell to rule out the use of fire-and-rehire altogether, but the motion was not accepted by the council administration, leaving the option formally on the table even as talks continue.
The role of the Scottish Government
Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth had already stepped in once before to help bring the council and unions together, reflecting the political sensitivity of a dispute involving one of Scotland’s largest local authorities and a workforce still recovering from the fallout of the original equal pay scandal, which became one of the highest-profile industrial disputes in recent Scottish local government history.
What happens next
The outcome of the renewed talks will determine whether Glasgow’s new pay structure is implemented, and on what terms, for a workforce that includes home carers, cleaners, school staff and many other frontline roles. Unions have indicated they will continue to resist any outcome that leaves low-paid staff worse off, while the council faces pressure to find a sustainable, affordable pay structure without reopening old equal pay wounds. No timetable has been set for when the talks might conclude.
Lessons from the original equal pay dispute
Glasgow’s original equal pay dispute ran for years before it was settled, eventually costing the council hundreds of millions of pounds in compensation to thousands of mostly female staff in roles such as home care, catering and cleaning that had been historically undervalued compared with male-dominated jobs attracting bonus payments. That history has made both unions and councillors acutely sensitive to any new grading system that could be seen as reproducing similar unfairness, explaining why the current dispute has attracted such high-profile political intervention.
Potential for industrial action
Unions involved in the dispute have previously balloted members or threatened industrial action in response to Glasgow council pay disputes, and a failure to reach agreement in the current round of talks would raise the prospect of similar action affecting council services relied upon by residents across the city, from schools to home care visits, should the row remain unresolved in the coming weeks.




