Katie Harrison of the Scottish Conservatives has won the Forth and Endrick by-election, securing a seat on Stirling Council after a contest held on Thursday 1 October.
The by-election was held to fill a vacancy in Ward 2, Forth and Endrick, one of Stirling Council’s multi-member wards, which uses the single transferable vote system common to all Scottish local government elections.
How the count unfolded
On first preferences, Ms Harrison led the field with 1,188 votes, ahead of the SNP’s Mhari Duncan on 1,057. Labour’s Paul Godzik took 380 first preferences, followed by the Greens’ Andrew Adam on 317, Reform UK’s Jeremy McDonald on 298, the Liberal Democrats’ James MacLaren on 175, and independent candidate Robert Davies on 55.
Because no candidate reached the quota required for outright election on first preferences, which was set at 1,736 votes, the contest went to successive rounds of vote transfers as lower-placed candidates were eliminated. Ms Harrison was ultimately declared elected at stage seven of the count, once transfers from eliminated candidates pushed her total over the quota.
Turnout and the mechanics of the vote
A total of 10,847 people were eligible to vote in the ward. Of these, 3,493 valid ballot papers were counted, giving a turnout of 32.2%, a figure broadly in line with turnout levels typically seen in Scottish council by-elections, which tend to be markedly lower than turnout at full council, Holyrood or Westminster elections. A further 23 ballot papers were rejected as invalid, for reasons such as being left blank or unclear.
Context for the result
The Forth and Endrick ward covers a largely rural part of Stirling Council’s area. By-elections of this kind are called when a sitting councillor resigns, dies in office or otherwise vacates their seat between scheduled elections, with the specific vacancy in this case arising ahead of the by-election date.
The result adds a seat for the Scottish Conservatives on Stirling Council, while the SNP’s second-place finish on first preferences reflects a competitive contest between the two parties in the ward. The relatively even spread of votes across seven candidates, spanning from Labour and the Greens to Reform UK and the Liberal Democrats, illustrates the fragmented nature of much of Scottish local politics beyond the two largest parties.
The returning officer’s response
Brian Roberts, Stirling Council’s chief executive, who also serves as the returning officer for council elections, congratulated Ms Harrison on her victory and thanked council staff involved in organising and running the count.
With the by-election concluded, Ms Harrison will take up her seat on Stirling Council representing Forth and Endrick alongside the ward’s other elected members, with the next scheduled full council elections due in 2027.
Why the seat was vacant
By-elections at ward level in Scotland are relatively infrequent and are typically triggered by the resignation or death of a sitting councillor partway through a four-year term. They offer a localised test of party support between the full council elections held across Scotland, and results are often watched closely by parties for signs of shifting voter sentiment ahead of national campaigns, even though turnout and circumstances in individual wards can vary considerably from wider trends.
How the single transferable vote works
Under the single transferable vote system used in Scottish council elections, voters rank candidates in order of preference rather than choosing only one. If no candidate meets the quota on first preferences, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated and their votes redistributed according to the next preference marked on each ballot, a process repeated until a candidate passes the quota, as happened in Forth and Endrick when Ms Harrison was elected at the seventh stage of counting.




