Scotland's councils could lose their existing role as the statutory bodies responsible for delivering school education under proposals in an independent report published by the Scottish Government. The report recommends creating Local Schools Authorities, alongside changes to how education funding is allocated and how schools work together. Ministers have not adopted the proposals: they have opened a three-month discussion with local authorities before deciding what to do.

The report, Shaping the Future: Strengthening Scotland's Education System Through Empowered Schools, was written by John J Wilson, the independent professional adviser for future school reform. Published on 28 September 2026, it examines the relationship between national government, councils and schools. Its recommendations raise a practical question for families and staff: who should be answerable for a school's resources and performance if the current structure changes?

A proposed change in responsibility

The central recommendation is for Local Schools Authorities to hold statutory responsibility for delivering school education. At present, Scotland's 32 local authorities play that role. The report also calls for a review of the way success is measured in schools, more straightforward sharing of good practice, and clearer arrangements for national education funding. These proposals concern governance across the system rather than an announcement that any particular school is moving to a new authority.

Wilson's report argues that schools should have more scope to make decisions responsive to pupils and local communities while remaining accountable for outcomes. It sets out a direction for reform, not a final map of future authorities or an implementation timetable. It would require decisions about what remains at council level, what moves to any new body and how money and accountability follow those responsibilities. Those decisions have yet to be made.

The report also examines the consistency with which councils record education spending and recommends a clearer definition and ring-fencing of national education funding. Ring-fencing would mean specifying the purpose of funds rather than allowing them to be used elsewhere in a council's wider budget. Whether that would improve school services, and what flexibility councils would lose, are questions for the coming discussion rather than settled outcomes of the report.

The scale of spending and local variation

The financial stakes are substantial. The report says overall direct Scottish Government funding to local authorities was projected at around £15.2bn in 2025-26. Education services were the largest category of councils' net revenue expenditure, with more than £8bn budgeted. The two figures measure different things and should not be added together: one is the overall funding settlement, the other a spending category within local government.

It cites differences in reported spending per pupil across Scotland's 32 councils. For secondary pupils, the figures range from £8,070 to £14,806, with a mean of £9,033; for primary pupils, from £6,686 to £13,100, with a mean of £7,412. Those ranges show differences in recorded spending, not proof by themselves that a council spending more is achieving better results, or that one spending less is failing pupils. Local geography, pupil needs and accounting practices have to be considered when interpreting comparisons.

That is partly why the recommendation on consistent recording matters. If councils categorise expenditure differently, headline comparisons can conceal what is being purchased or how much is reaching classrooms. The report proposes improving the basis on which education funds can be tracked, while its wider governance ideas would change who makes and oversees some of the spending decisions.

Ministers begin a discussion, not a transfer

Education Secretary Màiri McAllan welcomed the publication and referred to increases in National 5, Higher and Advanced Higher attainment and a second consecutive narrowing of the poverty-related attainment gap. She also acknowledged variation in outcomes between areas and schools. Those points are part of the government's response to the report, not an independent verdict that the proposed authorities would resolve the differences.

The Scottish Government says it will discuss the recommendations with local authorities over three months. Councils, which currently deliver school education, would be directly affected by any transfer of statutory responsibilities. Teachers, school leaders and families would also have an interest in whether a new arrangement changes day-to-day decisions, support services or lines of accountability. The publication does not itself alter their current arrangements.

The next substantive test is how ministers respond after the dialogue and whether they publish detailed proposals for the powers, boundaries and financing of Local Schools Authorities. Until that happens, the report is best understood as a set of recommendations for debate, not an enacted reform or a timetable for changing schools.