Scotland’s council umbrella body COSLA has raised what it calls serious concerns about Scottish government proposals to move social care under the control of the NHS, warning that the plans could weaken community-based support built up over decades.

The warning follows First Minister John Swinney’s announcement of a major restructuring of health services, designed to bring hospital and community care planning closer together and ease the pressure of delayed discharges on hospital beds.

What the government has proposed

Under the Programme for Government, ministers want to replace Scotland’s 14 territorial health boards with two strategic boards, one covering the east of the country and one the west. The idea is to simplify decision-making and give health planners a clearer line of sight between hospital capacity and the social care people need once they are well enough to leave.

Delayed discharge has been a persistent drain on the NHS in Scotland. Patients who are medically fit to go home can remain in hospital for days or weeks because a care package, a care home place or adapted housing is not available. Each such bed-day reduces the capacity available for new patients and contributes to pressure on accident and emergency departments.

The government has opened an engagement process with councils, health boards, unions and other stakeholders to work through how any new structure would operate in practice. Ministers have stressed that no final model has been agreed and that the Programme for Government sets a direction rather than a finished blueprint.

Why councils are worried

COSLA’s health and social care spokesperson, Paul Kelly, has argued that social work and social care do far more than simply help people leave hospital. Local authority services support people to live independently in their own communities, often for years, through home care, day services, housing adaptations and support for carers.

Councils fear that if decisions about social care are driven chiefly by NHS operational pressures, insufficient weight will be given to prevention, housing and the voluntary and community networks that keep people well in the first place. That, campaigners argue, risks storing up greater costs and worse outcomes later even if it eases short-term hospital pressures now.

There is also a question of democratic accountability. Social care in Scotland is currently delivered through a mixture of council functions and integration joint boards, which bring councils and health boards together locally. Moving more control to NHS structures raises questions about who would answer to communities for decisions on local services, and who would employ and manage social care staff.

The government’s case for change

Mr Swinney has argued that the NHS needs greater influence over the levers affecting care packages precisely because so many delays occur at the interface between hospitals and social care. When a patient cannot be discharged because a home care slot or care home bed is not available, the hospital bears the consequences even though the solution lies outside its direct control.

Supporters of reform say integrating planning more closely could reduce duplication and make it easier to move resources to wherever the pressure is greatest, whether that is in hospital wards or in the community.

What happens next

The engagement period is expected to run for roughly three months, during which councils, unions and other bodies will be able to put forward their concerns and suggestions. The detail of any new arrangement – including who would commission services, who would employ staff, and how communities would hold decision-makers to account – is likely to matter more in practice than the headline reduction from 14 boards to two.

No timetable for a final decision or any transfer of responsibilities has yet been set out. COSLA has indicated it will continue pressing for guarantees that local accountability and preventative services are protected whatever structure eventually emerges, while the Scottish government maintains that the overriding aim is a system that gets people home from hospital, and keeps them well at home, more reliably than at present.