Councils in England are underpaying for older people’s residential and nursing care by £2.36bn a year, with the gap between what it costs to provide care and what local authorities pay reaching its highest ever recorded level, according to a new report from Care England.

The trade body’s report, titled Priced to Fail, found the shortfall has grown by 49% in cash terms since 2022/23, and warns there is currently nothing in place to stop the gap widening further.

What the report found

Care England’s analysis found that the average council-funded residential care placement now carries an annual funding shortfall of more than £10,000, while the equivalent figure for nursing care placements exceeds £23,000 per bed.

The nursing care shortfall is described in the report as broadly equivalent to a care worker’s full annual salary, leaving providers to absorb the difference through operational efficiencies, delayed investment, postponed repairs and maintenance, or by limiting the number of publicly funded places they are able to offer.

The report also identifies a sharp regional disparity, with the weekly shortfall per nursing home resident ranging from £278 to £639 depending solely on where in England a person happens to live, pointing to what the report describes as a postcode lottery in care funding.

Why the gap has widened

Care England attributes the sharpest widening of the gap, a 27% increase seen in the most recent financial year alone, largely to the combined impact of rises in the National Living Wage and changes to employer National Insurance contributions, both of which have pushed up staffing costs for care providers without matching increases in the fees councils pay.

Care providers operate on tight margins, with staffing typically their largest cost. When government policy raises the wage bill across the sector but local authority fee increases do not keep pace, providers are left absorbing the difference, either by cutting back elsewhere or by reducing the number of council-funded beds they offer in favour of self-funded residents who can be charged more.

Reaction from the sector

Care England’s chief executive, Professor Martin Green, said there are around half a million people living in care homes in England, describing them as “our parents, our grandparents, people who built this country and paid into it their whole working lives on the understanding that it would be there for them when they needed it most”.

He said the £2.36bn shortfall showed that the system people are being asked to rely on is being underfunded, and that the gap is getting worse rather than better.

A long-running funding dispute

Care England has been tracking this gap for several years. A previous analysis in 2023 found councils underfunding older people’s care by just over £2bn during 2021/22, while the latest report shows the shortfall has grown substantially in cash terms since then. A separate assessment published last year found a £2.24bn gap between average local authority rates under the Market Sustainability and Improvement Fund and the forecast fair cost of care for 2024/25.

The government has previously pointed to multi-billion pound investment in social care over recent years as evidence of its commitment to the sector, though Care England argues that such funding has not kept pace with rising costs. The latest findings are likely to intensify pressure on ministers ahead of future spending decisions, with Care England warning that without a mechanism to close the gap, providers will continue to face difficult choices over staffing, investment and the number of publicly funded places they can sustainably offer.

How council care funding works

Local authorities in England are responsible for arranging and part-funding residential and nursing care for older people who are assessed as needing it and who do not have sufficient means to pay for it themselves, under a means-tested system set out in the Care Act 2014. Councils negotiate fee rates with care providers, intended in principle to reflect the “fair cost of care”, a concept introduced to ensure that rates paid to providers properly cover their costs rather than being set artificially low to manage council budgets.

In practice, Care England’s analysis suggests that fair cost of care principles have not been consistently applied, with many councils paying rates substantially below what providers say it actually costs to deliver safe, compliant care. Because councils operate under tight and often shrinking budgets, with social care competing against other pressing local spending priorities including children’s services and housing, fee rates for older people’s care have in many areas failed to keep pace with rising costs.

The knock-on effects for providers

Care providers facing a persistent funding gap have limited options: absorbing the shortfall through lower profit margins, where they exist at all; reducing non-essential spending such as maintenance, staff training or additional facilities; or declining to accept further council-funded residents in favour of self-funders who typically pay significantly higher fees. The latter option, often described in the sector as “cross-subsidisation”, effectively means self-funding residents and their families subsidise the cost of care for publicly funded residents in the same home, a practice long criticised by campaigners as an unfair and opaque feature of the English care market.

Smaller and independent care homes, which often have less financial reserve than larger chains, are considered particularly vulnerable to funding shortfalls of this scale, raising concerns about further care home closures in areas already short of capacity.

Broader reform efforts

Social care funding reform has been a recurring, and recurringly unresolved, feature of UK politics for more than two decades, with successive governments commissioning reviews, including the Dilnot Commission in 2011, that have recommended changes to the way care is funded without those recommendations being fully implemented. The current government has established its own independent review of adult social care, chaired by Baroness Louise Casey, tasked with recommending longer-term reform, though its fuller recommendations are not expected until later phases of its work, well beyond the immediate funding pressures highlighted in Care England’s report.

The workforce dimension

Staffing costs dominate care providers’ budgets, and the sector has faced acute recruitment and retention challenges in recent years, compounded by changes to immigration rules affecting the recruitment of care workers from overseas, who have historically filled a significant share of vacancies in the sector. Rises in the National Living Wage, while welcomed by many as improving pay for a historically low-paid workforce, have added further financial strain on providers when council fee increases do not keep pace, a dynamic Care England’s report highlights as central to the widening funding gap.

What might change

Any resolution to the funding gap identified by Care England would likely require either increased central government funding for adult social care passed through to councils, reform of how care is commissioned and paid for, or a combination of both. In the absence of such changes, Care England has warned that providers will continue to face difficult trade-offs between financial sustainability and the number of publicly funded places they can safely offer, a dynamic that risks further reducing access to care for older people who rely on council funding and have no other way to pay for the support they need.