Argyll and Bute Council has opened a public consultation on proposals to introduce a Short-Term Let Control Area covering several of its island and mainland communities, as it seeks to tackle the impact of holiday lets on local housing supply.
The proposed control area would span Mull and Iona, Coll and Tiree, Islay, Jura and Colonsay, and Lorn and the Inner Isles, a wide swathe of Argyll and Bute where short-term holiday letting has grown significantly in recent years.
What a control area changes
Under the proposal, anyone wanting to change a property that is not their main home into a short-term let would always need to apply for planning permission, rather than being able to do so without specific council approval, as is currently often the case. The council has stressed this is not a ban on short-term lets and would not apply retrospectively to existing properties already being let out.
Scotland introduced short-term let licensing across the country in 2022 and gave councils the power to designate control areas under planning law, allowing authorities in areas of particular housing pressure to require planning permission for new short-term lets created from secondary or non-primary homes. Several other Scottish local authorities, including Edinburgh, have already introduced similar control areas in response to concerns that the growth of holiday letting is reducing the stock of homes available for local residents.
Edinburgh’s control area, one of the first introduced in Scotland, has been cited by other councils considering similar measures as an early test case for how the policy operates in practice, including how planning officers assess applications for new lets within a designated area and how existing operators are treated differently from new entrants to the market.
The scale of the housing pressure
The council initially published data suggesting a very high proportion of housing in parts of the proposed area was unavailable as permanent homes, but subsequently corrected this figure, saying up to 38.8% of housing in some parts of the area is unavailable for permanent residence, lower than the original estimate. The council apologised for the inaccuracy in the data used in its original consultation material.
As a result of the error, the council extended the consultation period, pushing the closing date back to 15 November 2026 to give residents, businesses and other stakeholders more time to consider the corrected figures and respond.
The correction has drawn attention to the difficulty councils across rural and island Scotland face in gathering reliable, up-to-date data on how many properties are being used as holiday accommodation rather than permanent homes, a challenge that has complicated short-term let policymaking in several local authority areas since the national licensing scheme was introduced.
Balancing tourism and housing need
Council leader Jim Lynch acknowledged the importance of self-catering accommodation to the tourism economy of Argyll and Bute’s islands and coastal communities, which rely heavily on visitor spending, particularly during the summer season. At the same time, he said housing pressure is affecting local communities and services, including the ability of islands to retain working-age residents, support local schools and recruit staff for essential services such as healthcare.
The tension between tourism income and local housing availability has become a recurring issue across rural and island Scotland, with some communities reporting that the conversion of houses into holiday lets has made it harder for young people, key workers and families to find homes to rent or buy locally.
Island communities in particular have warned that losing even a small number of houses from the permanent housing stock can have an outsized effect on fragile local populations, since the loss of a handful of families can threaten the viability of a local primary school or make it harder for an employer to fill posts, concerns that have featured prominently in debates about housing and depopulation across the Hebrides and other parts of Argyll and Bute.
What happens after the consultation
Once the extended consultation closes on 15 November, the council will need to consider the responses received before deciding whether and how to proceed with formally designating the control area. Any final decision would need to balance the views of islanders concerned about housing availability against those of tourism businesses and second-home or holiday-let owners who may be affected by the new planning requirements.
Councillors are expected to return to the issue once consultation responses have been analysed, with officers likely to prepare a further report setting out options, including whether to proceed with the control area as originally proposed, adjust its boundaries, or reconsider elements of the policy in light of feedback received during the extended consultation window.




